What could be added or changed to make it more effective? How well does it tie everything together? To what extent does it make you want to learn more about this topic?

Questions for Peer Review

Questions for Peer Review, Problem/Solution Essay

Author’s Name: Reviewer’s Name:

How effectively does the introduction draw you into the paper? Why?

Comment on the writer’s focus. That is, how well does the writer stay on track or how much does the paper wander off course? If the paper loses focus, indicate where.

In the main part of the paper, are words or sentences that are confusing? Please highlight them in the author’s essay and if possible, explain why they are confusing. Can you offer suggestions for improvement?

Are there any parts of the paper that could use more explanation or description?

Reread the ending. What could be added or changed to make it more effective? How well does it tie everything together? To what extent does it make you want to learn more about this topic?